Multinational businesses

What you'll learn

This revision guide covers everything you need to know about multinational businesses for your CIE IGCSE Business Studies exam. You'll understand what makes a business multinational, why companies expand internationally, and the significant impacts these corporations have on host countries and their home nations. This topic links closely with business growth, globalisation, and stakeholder analysis.

Key terms and definitions

Multinational company (MNC) — a business that operates in more than one country, with production or service facilities outside its home nation

Host country — the country in which a multinational company invests and operates, but which is not the company's home base

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) — investment by a multinational company in production facilities, offices or other physical assets in another country

Joint venture — a business arrangement where two or more companies pool resources to create a separate business entity, often used when entering foreign markets

Transfer pricing — the practice of setting prices for goods and services sold between divisions of the same multinational company in different countries

Globalisation — the process by which businesses operate on an international scale, with increased interconnectedness between economies worldwide

Home country — the country where a multinational company has its headquarters and where it originated

Economies of scale — cost advantages gained by producing on a larger scale, which multinationals achieve through global operations

Core concepts

Characteristics of multinational businesses

Multinational companies are distinguished by several key features that separate them from purely domestic businesses.

Geographic spread

• Production facilities, offices or retail outlets in multiple countries
• Operations coordinated across international borders
• Examples include Unilever (operates in over 190 countries), Shell (operates in more than 70 countries), and Nestlé (factories in 86 countries)

Size and market power

• Usually large businesses with substantial revenue and employee numbers
• Significant market share in multiple national markets
• Brand recognition across different continents

Centralised strategic control

• Head office (usually in home country) makes major strategic decisions
• Financial control maintained from headquarters
• Local operations may have some autonomy for day-to-day decisions

International workforce

• Employees from many different nationalities
• Management teams that may relocate between countries
• Cultural diversity within the organisation

Reasons why businesses become multinationals

Companies expand internationally for several interconnected strategic reasons, each offering competitive advantages.

Access to new markets

• Increased customer base beyond saturated home markets
• Growing middle-class populations in emerging economies like India, Brazil, and Nigeria
• Higher sales revenue and profit potential
• Example: KFC expanded to China where it now has more outlets than in the USA

Lower production costs

• Cheaper labour in countries like Vietnam, Bangladesh, and parts of Eastern Europe
• Lower land and property costs
• Reduced transportation costs when producing closer to key markets
• Example: Apple manufactures in China partly due to lower production costs

Avoiding trade barriers

• Tariffs and quotas can make exporting expensive or difficult
• Setting up production inside a trade bloc (like the EU) avoids external tariffs
• Reduces impact of protectionist policies
• Example: Japanese car manufacturers established UK factories to access the European market

Access to natural resources

• Countries rich in raw materials like oil (Saudi Arabia), minerals (Democratic Republic of Congo), or agricultural products (Ivory Coast for cocoa)
• Securing supply chains
• Example: BP operates in oil-rich countries like Azerbaijan and Angola

Government incentives

• Tax breaks and subsidies offered by governments seeking investment
• Enterprise zones with reduced regulations
• Grants for job creation
• Example: Ireland attracted pharmaceutical multinationals with low corporate tax rates

Risk spreading

• Operating in multiple countries reduces dependence on one economy
• If recession hits one region, other markets may still perform well
• Currency fluctuations affect different markets differently

Benefits of multinationals to host countries

When multinational companies invest through FDI, host countries typically experience several positive impacts.

Employment creation

• Direct jobs in factories, offices, and retail outlets
• Indirect employment through suppliers and service providers
• Reduced unemployment rates
• Example: When Toyota built a plant in Derbyshire, UK, it created thousands of direct jobs

Skills and technology transfer

• Workers gain training and new technical skills
• Modern production techniques introduced
• Management expertise shared with local employees
• Improved productivity across the wider economy as skilled workers move to other employers

Infrastructure improvement

• Multinationals may fund roads, ports, and utilities to support their operations
• Benefits the wider community and other businesses
• Example: Mining companies in African nations have built roads and power supplies

Increased tax revenue

• Corporate taxes paid to host government
• Income tax from employees
• VAT/sales tax from increased economic activity
• Funds available for public services like education and healthcare

Export earnings

• If the multinational exports products made in the host country
• Improves the host country's balance of payments
• Brings foreign currency into the economy

Raised living standards

• Higher wages than local businesses sometimes pay
• Access to products and services previously unavailable
• Economic multiplier effect benefits suppliers and retailers

Drawbacks of multinationals to host countries

Despite the benefits, multinational operations can create significant problems for host nations.

Exploitation of workers

• May pay low wages compared to home country standards (though often higher than local alternatives)
• Poor working conditions in some cases
• Long hours with limited workers' rights
• Example: Garment factories in Bangladesh have faced criticism for safety standards

Environmental damage

• Pollution from factories (air, water, land)
• Depletion of natural resources
• Less strict environmental regulations in some host countries exploited
• Example: Oil companies have caused environmental damage in the Niger Delta

Profit repatriation

• Profits transferred back to home country rather than reinvested locally
• Reduces potential benefits to host economy
• Host country loses potential tax revenue if profits are not declared locally

Closure threats

• Multinationals can relocate production relatively easily
• Threatens job losses if wage demands increase
• Reduces bargaining power of workers and governments
• Example: Manufacturing firms have moved operations from China to Vietnam as Chinese wages increased

Domination of local businesses

• Superior resources and marketing power
• May drive local competitors out of business
• Reduced competition can lead to higher prices
• Cultural homogenisation as local brands disappear

Transfer pricing and tax avoidance

• Multinationals can manipulate prices between their own divisions in different countries
• Artificially reduces profits declared in high-tax countries
• Deprives host governments of legitimate tax revenue
• Example: Some technology companies have used Irish subsidiaries to reduce tax bills in other European countries

Benefits and drawbacks to home countries

The home country where a multinational is headquartered also experiences mixed effects.

Benefits to home country

• Tax revenue from repatriated profits (if declared)
• Headquarters jobs remain, often high-skilled and well-paid
• Exports of components or services to foreign operations
• Increased international prestige and influence
• Shareholders (often in home country) receive dividends

Drawbacks to home country

• Job losses as production moves overseas
• Deindustrialisation of traditional manufacturing regions
• Reduced income tax revenue from lost employment
• Skills may decline if production expertise moves abroad
• Example: UK manufacturing employment fell as companies relocated production to Asia

Social responsibilities of multinationals

Multinationals face pressure from various stakeholders regarding their ethical and social responsibilities, particularly given their significant power and resources.

Towards employees

• Fair wages and working conditions across all locations
• Health and safety standards that meet or exceed minimum legal requirements
• No discrimination based on gender, ethnicity, or religion
• Training and development opportunities

Environmental responsibilities

• Minimising carbon emissions and pollution
• Sustainable use of resources
• Waste management and recycling
• Renewable energy adoption
• Example: Unilever's Sustainable Living Plan commits to reducing environmental impact

Towards local communities

• Respect for local cultures and traditions
• Investment in community projects (schools, health facilities)
• Consultation with affected communities
• Fair compensation for land use

Ethical sourcing

• Ensuring suppliers meet ethical standards
• No child labour in supply chains
• Fair prices for suppliers in developing countries
• Transparency about supply chain practices

Pressure groups and NGOs like Oxfam, Greenpeace, and Fair Trade International monitor multinationals and campaign for improved practices, using negative publicity to encourage change.

Worked examples

Example 1: Identify and explain question

Question: Identify two reasons why a business might decide to become a multinational company. [2 marks]

Answer:

• To access new markets [1]
• To reduce production costs [1]

Examiner note: One mark per correct identification. No explanation required for an "identify" question.

---

Example 2: Explain question

Question: Explain two benefits to a host country of a multinational company locating a factory there. [6 marks]

Answer:

One benefit is employment creation [1]. When a multinational builds a factory, it directly employs workers in that country [1]. This reduces unemployment and means workers earn wages which they spend in the local economy, creating a multiplier effect [1].

A second benefit is skills and technology transfer [1]. The multinational will train local workers in modern production methods and technologies [1]. These workers may then take these skills to other employers or start their own businesses, raising productivity across the whole economy [1].

Examiner note: This is applying the classic CIE IGCSE structure for "Explain" questions: Point [1], Development [1], Context/Consequence [1] = 3 marks per explained point. Always aim for two well-developed points for a 6-mark explain question.

---

Example 3: Analysis/evaluation question

Question: Discuss whether a host country benefits overall from foreign direct investment by multinational companies. [8 marks]

Answer:

A host country can benefit significantly from FDI by multinationals. One major benefit is the creation of employment [1]. For example, when Nissan established its plant in Sunderland, UK, thousands of jobs were created directly and indirectly [1]. This reduces government spending on unemployment benefits and increases tax revenue from income tax [1]. The increased wages in the region also boost demand for local businesses [1].

However, there are also drawbacks that must be considered. Multinationals may exploit weaker environmental regulations in host countries [1]. For instance, some oil companies have caused significant pollution in the Niger Delta [1]. This leads to long-term environmental damage affecting health and livelihoods of local communities [1], which may outweigh the short-term economic benefits.

Another problem is profit repatriation [1]. Multinationals transfer profits back to their home country [1], meaning the host country loses potential investment and tax revenue [1].

Overall, whether a host country benefits depends on the specific circumstances. If the government negotiates strong regulations protecting workers and the environment, and ensures proper taxation, the benefits can outweigh the drawbacks. However, if multinationals are allowed to operate with minimal restrictions, the damage to the environment and exploitation of workers may mean the host country loses out in the long term. [evaluation]

Examiner note: For 8-mark questions, you need analysis (chains of reasoning), evaluation (weighing up both sides, making judgements), and a conclusion. This answer demonstrates developed chains of reasoning (Analysis marks) and reaches a balanced judgement (Evaluation marks).

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

• Confusing host and home country — Remember: host country is where the multinational invests (the guest); home country is where headquarters are located (where it started). Always check which the question asks about.

• One-sided answers to discuss/evaluate questions — Questions asking "Discuss whether..." or "Do you think..." require arguments on both sides. Always present benefits AND drawbacks before reaching a conclusion to access higher mark bands.

• Vague references to "helping the economy" — Be specific. Instead of writing "it helps the economy," explain exactly how: "increases employment, which raises income tax revenue for the government and reduces spending on unemployment benefits."

• Confusing a large business with a multinational — A company can be large but only operate in one country (like some supermarkets). A multinational must have operations (production or services) in multiple countries, not just sell there.

• Ignoring the question context — If a question specifies a particular type of business (e.g., manufacturing) or country (e.g., developing economy), tailor your answer to that context. Generic answers score lower marks.

• Listing points without explanation in explain questions — "Explain" requires development. Point + Development + Context/Consequence = full marks. Just listing reasons gets minimal marks.

Exam technique for "Multinational businesses"

• Command word awareness: "Identify" requires names only (no explanation). "Explain" needs developed chains of reasoning. "Discuss" and "Evaluate" require analysis of both sides plus a conclusion. Check the mark allocation — it guides how much detail you need.

• Use the mark scheme structure for explain questions: Aim for 2 fully developed points for 6 marks. Each point needs: initial point [1], development [1], and further development/consequence/context [1]. Three sentences per point is a good guide.

• Real-world examples strengthen answers: Named companies and countries make your answer more credible and can access context marks. You don't need obscure examples — well-known companies like Apple, Unilever, Nestlé, or Shell work perfectly.

• For evaluation questions, show judgement: Don't just list pros and cons. Make clear judgements like "this is more significant because..." or "the benefit outweighs the drawback when..." A conclusion that answers the question directly is essential for top marks.

Quick revision summary

Multinationals are businesses operating in multiple countries through production facilities or services, not just sales. Companies expand internationally to access markets, reduce costs, avoid trade barriers, and access resources. Host countries benefit from employment, skills transfer, and tax revenue, but may suffer exploitation, environmental damage, and profit repatriation. Home countries retain headquarters jobs and receive repatriated profits but may lose production jobs. Multinationals face increasing pressure to act responsibly regarding workers, environment, and communities. Exam success requires distinguishing host/home countries, balancing arguments in evaluation questions, and using specific examples.